Recapitulation

Early Church Understanding of Recapitulation

In the early Church, recapitulation (from the Latin recapitulatio, meaning “summing up” or “gathering together”) described Christ’s redemptive work as a comprehensive restoration of creation, rooted in Ephesians 1:10, where God’s plan is to “gather up all things in [Christ].” The doctrine, particularly articulated by Irenaeus, emphasized Christ’s role as the New Adam who reverses Adam’s disobedience and Mary’s role as the New Eve who counters Eve’s disobedience. Key aspects include:

• Christ as the New Adam and Mary as the New Eve: Christ’s obedience undoes Adam’s sin, while Mary’s fiat reverses Eve’s disobedience, together restoring humanity’s relationship with God.
• Fulfillment of Old Testament Types: Old Testament figures and events (e.g., Adam, Noah, Abraham) were seen as prefigurements that Christ and Mary fulfill and perfect.
• Cosmic Restoration: Recapitulation extends to all creation, renewing the harmony disrupted by the Fall.
• Holistic Redemption: Christ’s entire life—Incarnation, teachings, death, and resurrection—along with Mary’s cooperative role, contributes to recapitulation.

Recapitulation was a powerful tool against Gnostic heresies, which denied the goodness of creation and Christ’s humanity, affirming instead the unity of God’s redemptive plan across salvation history.

Recapitulation and the Old Testament

The early Church interpreted recapitulation through Old Testament typology, viewing Christ and Mary as fulfilling key figures and events that prefigured redemption. The Old Testament provided a narrative framework for understanding the Fall and its reversal. Key connections include:

• Adam, Eve, and the Fall (Genesis 3): The Fall introduced sin and death through Adam and Eve’s disobedience. The protoevangelium (Genesis 3:15), promising that the “seed” of the woman would crush the serpent, was seen as a prophecy of Christ, born of Mary, defeating sin. Christ and Mary recapitulate Adam and Eve’s roles, restoring humanity’s original state.
• Noah and the Flood (Genesis 6-9): Noah’s ark, preserving creation, prefigured Christ’s redemptive work, with the Church as the new ark. Mary’s role as the ark of the New Covenant, bearing Christ, was seen as integral to this restoration.
• Abraham’s Covenant (Genesis 12:1-3): The promise to bless all nations through Abraham’s seed was fulfilled in Christ, with Mary as the faithful mother who enables the seed’s coming (Galatians 3:16).
• Moses and the Law (Exodus 19-24): The Mosaic Law’s sacrificial system was a temporary guide, fulfilled by Christ’s perfect sacrifice and Mary’s obedient cooperation in God’s plan.
• Davidic Kingdom (2 Samuel 7): The eternal kingdom promised to David was recapitulated in Christ’s reign, with Mary as the queen mother, a role rooted in Old Testament tradition (e.g., 1 Kings 2:19).

The early Church saw these figures and events as types that Christ and Mary fulfilled, summing up and perfecting salvation history through their redemptive roles.

The New Testament on Recapitulation

The New Testament provides the scriptural foundation for recapitulation, portraying Christ as the New Adam who restores creation and implicitly linking Mary to Eve’s role. Key passages include:

• Ephesians 1:9-10: Paul describes God’s plan “to gather up all things in [Christ], things in heaven and things on earth,” emphasizing the cosmic scope of recapitulation.
• Romans 5:12-21: Paul contrasts Adam’s disobedience, which brought sin and death, with Christ’s obedience, which brings justification and life: “For just as through the disobedience of the one man the many were made sinners, so also through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous” (Romans 5:19). This establishes Christ as the New Adam.
• 1 Corinthians 15:21-22: Paul reinforces the Adam-Christ parallel: “For since death came through a human being, the resurrection of the dead has also come through a human being; for as all die in Adam, so all will be made alive in Christ.” Christ recapitulates humanity’s history, restoring life.
• Galatians 4:4-5: “When the fullness of time had come, God sent his Son, born of a woman, born under the law, to redeem those who were under the law.” This highlights Mary’s role in the Incarnation, enabling Christ’s redemptive mission.
• Luke 1:38: Mary’s fiat, “Let it be with me according to your word,” contrasts with Eve’s disobedience, positioning her as the New Eve who cooperates in redemption.

While the New Testament does not explicitly call Mary the New Eve, her role as the mother of the Redeemer implicitly parallels Eve, supporting the early Church’s recapitulation theology.

The Church Fathers on Recapitulation, Adam, Eve, Jesus, and Mary

The Church Fathers, especially Irenaeus, developed recapitulation to articulate Christ’s and Mary’s roles in reversing the Fall, fulfilling Old Testament types, and restoring creation. Their views on Adam, Eve, and the Fall in relation to Jesus and Mary include:

• Irenaeus of Lyons (Against Heresies, c. 180 AD): Irenaeus is the primary architect of recapitulation, emphasizing Christ as the New Adam and Mary as the New Eve. He wrote, “As Eve was seduced by the word of an angel to flee from God… so the Virgin Mary received the good news by the word of an angel” (Against Heresies 5.19.1). Christ’s obedience reverses Adam’s disobedience, while Mary’s fiat counters Eve’s rebellion, enabling the Incarnation. Irenaeus saw the Fall as a disruption of God’s plan, which Christ and Mary restore through their cooperative obedience, fulfilling Old Testament types like the protoevangelium.¹
• Justin Martyr (Dialogue with Trypho, c. 150 AD): Justin linked Mary to Eve, stating, “Eve, a virgin, conceived the word of the serpent… but Mary, a virgin, conceived the Word of God” (Dialogue 100). He saw Christ as fulfilling Old Testament types (e.g., the suffering servant, Passover lamb) and Mary as the obedient virgin who enables redemption, contrasting Eve’s disobedience. Christ recapitulates Israel’s history, uniting all nations.²
• Athanasius of Alexandria (On the Incarnation, c. 318 AD): Athanasius focused on Christ as the New Adam, restoring the divine image lost in the Fall: “He became man that we might become divine” (On the Incarnation 54). While less explicit about Mary, he saw her as the means through which Christ assumed humanity, enabling recapitulation. The Fall corrupted creation, but Christ’s life and death restore it, fulfilling Old Testament promises.³
• Augustine of Hippo (City of God, c. 413-426 AD): Augustine viewed the Fall as humanity’s lapse into sin through Adam and Eve’s disobedience. Christ, as the New Adam, restores humanity through his obedience, and Mary, as the New Eve, cooperates by her faith: “Through a woman came death; through a woman came life” (Sermon 232). The Church, as the body of Christ, continues this recapitulation, uniting all peoples under the New Covenant.⁴
• Tertullian (On the Flesh of Christ, c. 210 AD): Tertullian emphasized Mary’s role as the New Eve, contrasting her obedience with Eve’s disobedience: “As Eve believed the serpent, so Mary believed the angel” (On the Flesh of Christ 17). He saw Christ’s Incarnation and death as recapitulating Adam’s role, restoring humanity’s dignity and fulfilling Old Testament types.⁵

The Fathers understood the Fall as a cosmic rupture caused by Adam and Eve’s disobedience, which Christ and Mary reverse through their obedience. Christ’s entire life—Incarnation, teachings, death, and resurrection—recapitulates human history, while Mary’s fiat enables the Incarnation, making her a cooperator in redemption. This theology affirmed the unity of salvation history and the goodness of creation against Gnostic dualism.

Conclusion

The early Church’s doctrine of recapitulation, most fully developed by Irenaeus, presented Christ as the New Adam and Mary as the New Eve, reversing the Fall and fulfilling Old Testament types. The New Testament establishes Christ’s role in restoring creation (Ephesians 1:10, Romans 5:12-21) and implicitly supports Mary’s role through her obedience (Luke 1:38). The Church Fathers, including Justin, Irenaeus, Athanasius, Augustine, and Tertullian, elaborated on recapitulation, emphasizing Christ’s and Mary’s roles in countering Adam and Eve’s disobedience, fulfilling figures like Noah, Abraham, and Moses, and restoring creation. The Fall was seen as a disruption of God’s plan, which Christ’s redemptive work and Mary’s cooperation restore, offering a holistic vision of redemption. From a Roman Catholic perspective, recapitulation remains a vital framework, integrating the Old Testament’s preparatory role with the New Covenant’s fulfillment, affirming the transformative power of Christ and Mary in salvation history.

Footnotes

return to top ⇑