Church Councils & Early Creeds

Early Christian Creeds and Church Councils 

The early centuries of Christianity were marked by both rapid growth and intense doctrinal challenges. As the Church spread across the Roman Empire, it faced increasing theological disputes and pastoral needs that required clear articulation of the apostolic faith. To safeguard orthodoxy, define doctrine, and maintain ecclesial unity, the Church developed creeds and convened synods and councils—both local and ecumenical. These gatherings were not abstract theological exercises but vital responses to heresies and misunderstandings that threatened to fracture the unity and identity of the Church.

The Old Roman Symbol (c. 100–120 A.D.)

One of the earliest known Christian creeds, the Old Roman Symbol was used as a baptismal confession in the Church of Rome. Though brief and undeveloped compared to later formulations, it contained the core of Christian belief in the Trinity, the Incarnation, the Passion, Resurrection, and Ascension of Jesus. Its simplicity reflects the apostolic faith as handed down in the immediate post-apostolic age. It is the forerunner of what would become the Apostle’s Creed and served as a rule of faith for catechumens preparing for baptism in an era when oral tradition and episcopal teaching held sway against Gnostic distortions.¹

Synod of Rome (c. 193 A.D.)

The Synod of Rome, convened under Pope Victor I, was the first notable attempt at resolving a widespread liturgical dispute. The issue at hand was the celebration of Easter—whether it should be held on the 14th of Nisan (the Jewish Passover date) or always on a Sunday. This disagreement, known as the Quartodeciman Controversy, threatened Church unity. The Roman position, favoring Sunday observance, eventually prevailed, laying early groundwork for the idea of a central ecclesial authority helping to arbitrate practice across diverse local churches.²

The Apostle’s Creed (c. 150–180 A.D.)

Developed from the Old Roman Symbol, the Apostle’s Creed gained wide usage in the West by the mid-second century. It was not composed by the apostles themselves, but it claimed apostolic authority as a faithful summary of their teaching. The creed expanded slightly on earlier formulas by emphasizing Christ’s birth of the Virgin Mary, His descent into hell, and the resurrection of the body. It also functioned catechetically and liturgically, especially in baptisms. Importantly, it defended orthodoxy against the dual threats of Gnosticism and Docetism by affirming Christ’s true humanity and bodily resurrection.³

Synods of Carthage (251 & 256 A.D.)

Presided over by St. Cyprian of Carthage, these synods addressed the treatment of the lapsi—Christians who had renounced the faith under persecution—and the validity of baptisms performed by heretics. Cyprian argued that baptisms outside the Church were invalid, opposing Pope Stephen I who upheld their validity. Though the issue remained unresolved for a time, the controversy highlighted emerging tensions between local episcopal autonomy and Roman primacy. These synods were also crucial for articulating a theology of penance and ecclesial communion during the Decian persecution.⁴

Synod of Neocæsarea (c. 315 A.D.)

Held in the region of Pontus, this lesser-known council issued canons regulating clerical conduct, particularly concerning ordination and celibacy. Among the most notable was the prohibition of priests marrying after ordination. The synod’s disciplinary canons reflect an increasingly structured view of the clerical state and the development of canonical norms that would inform later councils in East and West.⁵

First Ecumenical Council: Nicaea (325 A.D.)

The First Council of Nicaea, convened by Emperor Constantine, marked a pivotal turning point in Church history. It was called to address the Arian heresy, which denied the full divinity of the Son by claiming He was a created being. Under the leadership of bishops like Alexander of Alexandria and the young deacon Athanasius, the council formulated the Nicene Creed, declaring the Son to be homoousios (of the same substance) with the Father. This theological precision preserved the doctrine of the Trinity and established the precedent for imperial convocation of councils. A popular (though legendary) tale records St. Nicholas of Myra striking Arius during the proceedings—a symbol of fervent orthodoxy, whether literally true or not.⁶

The Nicene Creed (325 A.D.)

The Nicene Creed was the most theologically significant product of the Council of Nicaea. It definitively rejected Arianism and provided the first dogmatic definition of the Son’s consubstantiality with the Father. This creed became the standard of orthodoxy and is still recited today in Christian liturgy, albeit often in its 381 form. Its impact on Christology and Trinitarian doctrine cannot be overstated—it laid the foundation for all subsequent theological developments in the Church.⁷

Synod of Laodicea (c. 363 A.D.)

Held in Asia Minor, the Synod of Laodicea issued numerous canons on Christian discipline and liturgical practice. Among the most important was Canon 59, which forbade the reading of non-canonical books in Church—a sign of the emerging Christian canon. The council also regulated Sunday observance, clerical behavior, and Christian participation in pagan festivals, reflecting the Church’s growing institutional identity in a post-persecution world.⁸

Second Ecumenical Council: Constantinople (381 A.D.)

This council, convened by Emperor Theodosius I, reaffirmed and expanded the Nicene Creed. It was called to confront semi-Arianism and Macedonianism (which denied the full divinity of the Holy Spirit). The council condemned Apollinarianism and affirmed the full humanity and divinity of Christ. Gregory of Nazianzus played a key role, though he resigned early. The council’s revised creed—often called the Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed—became the definitive Trinitarian formula of Eastern and Western Christianity.⁹

Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed (381 A.D.)

This creed built upon the 325 version by expanding the section on the Holy Spirit and affirming the Church, baptism, resurrection, and eternal life. It cemented the doctrine of the Trinity: one God in three Persons, each fully and equally divine. Its recitation in liturgy remains a powerful testimony to the Church’s unified theological witness.¹⁰

Synod of Rome (382 A.D.)

Chaired by Pope Damasus I, this synod was instrumental in listing the canonical books of Scripture, mirroring the list later ratified in North African councils. The council’s decisions were shaped by the influence of St. Jerome, who began work on the Latin Vulgate shortly thereafter. This synod helped solidify the biblical canon in the West, influencing centuries of Catholic doctrine and liturgical readings.¹¹

The Creed of Jerusalem (c. 350 A.D.)

Attributed to St. Cyril of Jerusalem, this creed was used for catechumens preparing for baptism in the Church of Jerusalem. While not formally adopted by an ecumenical council, its language and structure influenced the later Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed. It reflects a period when localized creeds helped preserve doctrinal integrity amid Arian influence and served pastoral needs in a liturgically rich context.¹²

Synod of Hippo (393 A.D.) & Synod of Carthage (397 A.D.)

These two North African synods were critical in affirming the canon of Scripture. The list of books they approved for the Old and New Testaments matches the canon later ratified at the Council of Trent. Spearheaded by figures like St. Augustine, these councils also addressed clerical discipline, catechesis, and liturgical practice. Their role in canon formation marked a key moment in the Church’s consolidation of Scripture and doctrine.¹³

Third Ecumenical Council: Ephesus (431 A.D.)

The Council of Ephesus was called to condemn Nestorianism, which taught that Christ was two distinct persons (one divine and one human). Led by St. Cyril of Alexandria, the council affirmed that Mary is Theotokos (“God-bearer”), since she bore the one Person of Christ who is both God and man. This council was critical for Christological unity and for affirming the union of divinity and humanity in Jesus Christ.¹⁴

Fourth Ecumenical Council: Chalcedon (451 A.D.)

This monumental council responded to the Monophysite controversy by defining the doctrine of the two natures of Christ—divine and human—in one Person “without confusion, without change, without division, without separation.” Pope Leo I’s Tome played a decisive role, articulating the Roman Church’s Christology. The resulting Chalcedonian Creed became the standard for orthodoxy in the West and much of the East, though some Eastern Christians rejected it, leading to the Oriental Orthodox split.¹⁵

Chalcedonian Creed (451 A.D.)

The Chalcedonian Definition stands as one of the most theologically precise Christological statements in history. It safeguarded the mystery of the Incarnation from reductionist interpretations, affirming that Christ is fully God and fully man. This definition preserved Christian teaching against both Nestorian and Monophysite errors, and it remains foundational in Catholic, Orthodox, and many Protestant traditions.¹⁶

Conclusion

The early creeds and councils were not abstract exercises in dogma but urgent, pastoral responses to crises that threatened the identity and unity of the Church. From the Old Roman Symbol to the Council of Chalcedon, the Church slowly and carefully defined the mystery of Christ, the Trinity, and the canon of Scripture. In doing so, it bequeathed to future generations the creeds and confessions that still structure Christian belief today.

return to top ⇑